In most Portland deals, I ask the seller for a credit. A credit is the easiest thing for a seller to say yes to, it keeps the closing on schedule, and it lets you hire your own contractor once the house is yours. The exception is high-risk work: the kind of repair where a contractor opens up a wall in a 100-year-old house or digs up an old sewer line, and the cost can keep growing once they start. When the item is that risky and my buyers don't want to carry that risk, I push for the seller to do the repair before closing, with conditions that give us some control over the work.
Here's how I think through it, with two real examples.
What's the difference between a repair and a credit?
A credit lowers the amount of money you have to bring to closing. The seller isn't doing any work. After you close, you use that money to hire whatever contractor you want.
A repair is done before closing, and the seller pays for it. That also means the seller decides who does the work and what the finished product looks like. You get a fixed problem on day one, but you give up control over how it was fixed.
That tradeoff, control versus risk, is the whole decision.
When a credit is the better move
A credit usually makes sense when the problem is well defined, you can get a solid bid on it, and you'd rather pick the contractor yourself. Sellers also tend to approve credits more easily because they don't have to manage a project while they're trying to move.
Here's a roof negotiation I worked on recently. The inspection turned up several areas that needed patching and some exposed nail heads. My buyers' roofer recommended a full replacement at about $12,000, so that's what we asked for.
The seller pushed back, and fairly. The roof still had some life left in it, so a full replacement was really an early upgrade, not a fix for a failed roof. The seller offered $8,000 of the $12,000. My buyers accepted, because they knew they were asking to replace the roof before the end of its life.
How we structured it is worth knowing. My buyers' roofer was scheduled to start the day after closing. At closing, the seller's $8,000 was paid directly to the roofing company through escrow, and my buyers paid the remaining $4,000 once the work was done. The house appraised as-is, not subject to the roof work, so this didn't have to be set up as a holdback. My buyers kept their own roofer and still got the seller to fund most of the job.
If you want to do something similar, bring in your lender and escrow officer early so everyone agrees on how the money will move.
When I push for the seller to do the repair
I lean toward a repair when the problem is high-risk and the cost could grow once work starts. Sewer lines and anything that means opening walls in an older home are the usual examples. If the scope grows after you close, that's your problem. If it grows before closing, it's the seller's.
I recently negotiated this exact question on an older home. The sewer scope showed tree roots running through the line between the house and the main. The line used to be a shared party line, since decommissioned, and it runs under a driveway shared with the neighbor. That's a complicated repair with a lot of unknowns, and my buyers didn't want to take that risk on themselves, so they wanted the seller to handle it.
There was a real case for a credit, too. A credit would have kept the closing date from slipping, and my buyers would have had final say over who did the work. On a repair this complicated, choosing the contractor matters. Neither option was obviously right. It came down to how much risk my buyers were willing to carry against how much control they wanted.
How I protect buyers when the seller handles the repair
The weakness of a seller repair is that the seller picks the contractor, and the seller wants it done at a reasonable cost. So when we go the repair route, I build in some protections:
- The work has to be done by a licensed contractor.
- The seller provides written invoices for the completed work.
- For sewer repairs, we get a follow-up sewer scope to confirm the fix.
- I do a final walkthrough on any completed work to get a second set of eyes on it.
- If something looks off, we bring an inspector back out to re-inspect that item.
You won't get the same control as hiring the contractor yourself, but you're not taking the seller's word for it either.
What if the credit you need is bigger than your loan allows?
This comes up more than buyers expect. Lenders limit how much a seller can credit you, and I've had several deals where the credits we wanted would have gone over that limit.
When that happens, we usually have two options. We can shift some items to seller repairs, or we can ask for a price reduction. A price reduction lowers your mortgage payment, but it doesn't give you cash to do the work after closing. If you need the money to fix something right away, a lower price doesn't really solve your problem.
Ask your lender early what the maximum seller credit is for your specific loan, before you write your repair request.
Why Portland's older homes change the math
In my experience, Portland sellers are more willing to cover health and safety items than cosmetic ones. A lot of that comes from the age of the housing stock here. The issues I see come up again and again:
- Sewer lines that are failing, root-filled, or both.
- Knob and tube electrical, which in my experience can make it hard to get homeowners insurance.
- Radon in basements.
- Foundation cracks and settling in homes that are 100 years old.
- Oil tanks. We do an oil tank sweep to check whether there's ever been a tank on the property and, if there was, whether it was properly decommissioned. If we can't find decommissioning records with the Oregon DEQ and we do find a tank, we do a soil sample to make sure it hasn't leaked. A leak means an environmental cleanup, and that can get expensive.
These are the items worth spending your negotiating power on.
The biggest mistake: asking for everything
The most common mistake I see is a repair request that asks for everything without setting priorities. Every small item makes the seller feel nickel-and-dimed, and that makes it harder to get the one thing you actually need.
Items a seller can easily dismiss as upgrades hurt you most. If your list mixes a failing sewer line with a sticky door and some dated fixtures, the seller sees a buyer who's going to be difficult, not a buyer with a serious safety concern. If you lead with the health and safety items and drop the small stuff, your big ask carries a lot more weight.
So what should you ask for?
When buyers ask me what they should do, here's my usual answer. Where I can, I ask for credits, because they keep the deal moving and leave my buyers in control of the work. When there's a high-risk item and my buyers are risk-averse, I'm more likely to ask for a repair, as long as we can keep some control over how it gets done.
The right answer depends on the specific problem, how much risk you're willing to carry, and what your loan allows. I'm going to be straightforward: there's no single rule that works for every inspection.
If you're moving in the next 12-18 months, call or text me at 971-443-1770 and we can schedule some time to talk through your specific situation. You can also email me at kerrie@kdrealestatepdx.com or book a 30-minute call.
About the author
Kerrie Doerr is a Broker with KD Real Estate at eXp Realty, based on Portland's inner eastside. She works mostly with buyers relocating to Portland and handles inspection and repair negotiations for her clients from offer to closing. Oregon license #201261984.

